October
05, 2012
You've heard the phrase so many times, it's hardly worth more
than a lukewarm cup of coffee.
"Best in America" might be a bit tired, but that
hasn't stopped Dunkin' Donuts from trying to own it. On Sept. 26, the company
filed to register the phrase "Best Coffee In America" as a trademark
with the United States Patent and Trademark Office. If the office approves the
request, Dunkin' Donuts will own the exclusive rights to use the words to sell
coffee, the Boston Globe reported.
In the past, the Patent and Trademark Office has sometimes
declined to grant registered trademarks for phrases like "Best in
America." When the Boston Beer Company sought to claim the phrase "Best
Beer in America," the office said the wording was too generic for any one
company to own as a trademark.
Typically, companies trying to register trademarks in common
phrases or images argue that they have acquired secondary meanings associated
with the product or service the company sells. In 2006, Walmart tried
unsuccessfully to trademark the smiley face,
claiming that the image had become associated with its stores in the retail
sector.
While hyperbolic language has long been used to convince people
to buy stuff they don't need, "best in the world" superlatives became
popular in the 19th century as trains and steamships made travel across the
country and world easier, Dennis Waring writes in the book Manufacturing
the Muse: "As overseas transport became more
feasible ... language such as 'the oldest in the world,' 'the largest in the
world,' and the 'best in the world' came into vogue."